Pump Performance Comparison

Intelligent side-by-side analysis powered by APE engineering expertise

10 Pumps Analyzed
504.0 m³/hr Required
192.0 m Head Required
Application Requirements
Flow Rate: 504.0 m³/hr
Head: 192.0 m
Application: Water Supply
Liquid: Clean Water

📊 Detailed Performance Comparison

Compare key specifications and performance metrics across all pump options

sort Sort by:
Parameter
PL 200 AS
8X10X13 2S
8/10 GME
PL 200 AN
18 HC 1214 4P 6ST SABS
8X10X13 2S NEW
8X10X13 3S NEW
8X10X13 4S NEW
VBK 420/018-4S
MSD 10x10x13.5 3(4)
Add to Shortlist
Overall Score 72.1/100 59.3/100 58.5/100 56.4/100 55.6/100 55.5/100 50.0/100 49.6/100 44.3/100 41.0/100
Pump Type
Efficiency (%) 60.0% 84.5% 75.0% 80.0% 67.7% 85.0% 85.8% 85.8% 67.7% 80.3%
Power Consumption (kW) 439.5 453.6 383.1 329.6 415.1 458.2 674.1 908.6 399.7 755.0
Head Accuracy 192.0m 279.0m 209.2m 192.0m 204.7m 283.6m 420.9m 567.5m 197.0m 441.3m
Impeller Size (mm)
Operating Point Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range
Selection Reason Efficiency: 60.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 84.5%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 75.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 80.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 67.7%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 85.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 85.8%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 85.8%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 67.7%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 80.3%, Head error: 0.0%
Actions

* Indicates extrapolated values beyond tested curve range

💰 Lifecycle Cost Analysis

Compare operating costs and long-term financial impact over 10-year lifespan

Annual Energy Cost
PL 200 AS
R9,624,787/year
439.5 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
8X10X13 2S
R9,933,380/year
453.6 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
8/10 GME
R8,390,416/year
383.1 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
PL 200 AN
R7,218,590/year
329.6 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
18 HC 1214 4P 6ST SABS
R9,090,471/year
415.1 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
8X10X13 2S NEW
R10,035,303/year
458.2 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
8X10X13 3S NEW
R14,762,527/year
674.1 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
8X10X13 4S NEW
R19,899,435/year
908.6 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
VBK 420/018-4S
R8,753,189/year
399.7 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
MSD 10x10x13.5 3(4)
R16,534,040/year
755.0 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
10-Year Total Cost
PL 200 AS
R146,248
Initial + 10-year energy cost
8X10X13 2S
R149,334
Initial + 10-year energy cost
8/10 GME
R133,904
Initial + 10-year energy cost
PL 200 AN
R122,186
Initial + 10-year energy cost
18 HC 1214 4P 6ST SABS
R140,905
Initial + 10-year energy cost
8X10X13 2S NEW
R150,353
Initial + 10-year energy cost
8X10X13 3S NEW
R197,625
Initial + 10-year energy cost
8X10X13 4S NEW
R248,994
Initial + 10-year energy cost
VBK 420/018-4S
R137,532
Initial + 10-year energy cost
MSD 10x10x13.5 3(4)
R215,340
Initial + 10-year energy cost
Annual Cost Comparison
PL 200 AS
Baseline
Reference point
8X10X13 2S
-R308,593/year
Additional cost vs baseline
8/10 GME
+R1,234,372/year
Cost savings vs baseline
PL 200 AN
+R2,406,197/year
Cost savings vs baseline
18 HC 1214 4P 6ST SABS
+R534,316/year
Cost savings vs baseline
8X10X13 2S NEW
-R410,516/year
Additional cost vs baseline
8X10X13 3S NEW
-R5,137,740/year
Additional cost vs baseline
8X10X13 4S NEW
-R10,274,648/year
Additional cost vs baseline
VBK 420/018-4S
+R871,598/year
Cost savings vs baseline
MSD 10x10x13.5 3(4)
-R6,909,253/year
Additional cost vs baseline
Cost Analysis Summary
Most Efficient: 8X10X13 4S NEW (85.8% efficiency)
Lowest Operating Cost: PL 200 AN (R7,218,590/year)
Annual Cost Range: R12,680,845 difference between highest and lowest
10-Year Impact: R126,808,446 total savings potential

🔧 Individual Pump Overview

Detailed cards view with performance metrics and direct actions for each pump option

BEST MATCH

PL 200 AS

72.1
Overall Score
Efficiency 60.0%
Power 439.5 kW
Head 192.0 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 2

8X10X13 2S

59.3
Overall Score
Efficiency 84.5%
Power 453.6 kW
Head 279.0 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 3

8/10 GME

58.5
Overall Score
Efficiency 75.0%
Power 383.1 kW
Head 209.2 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 4

PL 200 AN

56.4
Overall Score
Efficiency 80.0%
Power 329.6 kW
Head 192.0 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 5

18 HC 1214 4P 6ST SABS

55.6
Overall Score
Efficiency 67.7%
Power 415.1 kW
Head 204.7 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 6

8X10X13 2S NEW

55.5
Overall Score
Efficiency 85.0%
Power 458.2 kW
Head 283.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 7

8X10X13 3S NEW

50.0
Overall Score
Efficiency 85.8%
Power 674.1 kW
Head 420.9 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 8

8X10X13 4S NEW

49.6
Overall Score
Efficiency 85.8%
Power 908.6 kW
Head 567.5 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 9

VBK 420/018-4S

44.3
Overall Score
Efficiency 67.7%
Power 399.7 kW
Head 197.0 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 10

MSD 10x10x13.5 3(4)

41.0
Overall Score
Efficiency 80.3%
Power 755.0 kW
Head 441.3 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
picture_as_pdfDownload Comparison Report arrow_backNew Selection