Pump Performance Comparison

Intelligent side-by-side analysis powered by APE engineering expertise

10 Pumps Analyzed
328.1 m³/hr Required
106.6 m Head Required
Application Requirements
Flow Rate: 328.1 m³/hr
Head: 106.6 m
Application: Water Supply
Liquid: Clean Water

📊 Detailed Performance Comparison

Compare key specifications and performance metrics across all pump options

sort Sort by:
Parameter
SCP 150/580HA-132/4
6/8 DME
6/8 DMP
6/8 EME
PJ 200 AS
VBK 35-22.5 3 STAGE
PL 200 AN
100-250 2F 2P
150-125-315
VBK 35-22 3 Stage
Add to Shortlist
Overall Score 87.2/100 84.3/100 84.3/100 74.5/100 74.2/100 72.2/100 68.8/100 68.0/100 67.2/100 66.7/100
Pump Type
Efficiency (%) 77.9% 80.0% 80.0% 79.2% 64.0% 66.2% 78.7% 78.0% 74.9% 59.0%
Power Consumption (kW) 132.2 119.1 119.1 141.7 148.9 144.0 134.3 122.2 156.6 161.5
Head Accuracy 115.2m 106.6m 106.6m 125.6m 106.6m 106.6m 118.2m 106.6m 131.2m 106.6m
Impeller Size (mm)
Operating Point Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range Within Range
Selection Reason Efficiency: 77.9%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 80.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 80.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 79.2%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 64.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 66.2%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 78.7%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 78.0%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 74.9%, Head error: 0.0% Efficiency: 59.0%, Head error: 0.0%
Actions

* Indicates extrapolated values beyond tested curve range

💰 Lifecycle Cost Analysis

Compare operating costs and long-term financial impact over 10-year lifespan

Annual Energy Cost
SCP 150/580HA-132/4
R2,896,209/year
132.2 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
6/8 DME
R2,609,056/year
119.1 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
6/8 DMP
R2,609,056/year
119.1 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
6/8 EME
R3,102,682/year
141.7 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
PJ 200 AS
R3,261,326/year
148.9 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
VBK 35-22.5 3 STAGE
R3,152,943/year
144.0 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
PL 200 AN
R2,942,112/year
134.3 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
100-250 2F 2P
R2,675,961/year
122.2 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
150-125-315
R3,430,175/year
156.6 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
VBK 35-22 3 Stage
R3,537,704/year
161.5 kW × 8760h × R2.49/kWh
10-Year Total Cost
SCP 150/580HA-132/4
R78,962
Initial + 10-year energy cost
6/8 DME
R76,091
Initial + 10-year energy cost
6/8 DMP
R76,091
Initial + 10-year energy cost
6/8 EME
R81,027
Initial + 10-year energy cost
PJ 200 AS
R82,613
Initial + 10-year energy cost
VBK 35-22.5 3 STAGE
R81,529
Initial + 10-year energy cost
PL 200 AN
R79,421
Initial + 10-year energy cost
100-250 2F 2P
R76,760
Initial + 10-year energy cost
150-125-315
R84,302
Initial + 10-year energy cost
VBK 35-22 3 Stage
R85,377
Initial + 10-year energy cost
Annual Cost Comparison
SCP 150/580HA-132/4
Baseline
Reference point
6/8 DME
+R287,153/year
Cost savings vs baseline
6/8 DMP
+R287,153/year
Cost savings vs baseline
6/8 EME
-R206,473/year
Additional cost vs baseline
PJ 200 AS
-R365,117/year
Additional cost vs baseline
VBK 35-22.5 3 STAGE
-R256,734/year
Additional cost vs baseline
PL 200 AN
-R45,902/year
Additional cost vs baseline
100-250 2F 2P
+R220,248/year
Cost savings vs baseline
150-125-315
-R533,966/year
Additional cost vs baseline
VBK 35-22 3 Stage
-R641,495/year
Additional cost vs baseline
Cost Analysis Summary
Most Efficient: 6/8 DME (80.0% efficiency)
Lowest Operating Cost: 6/8 DME (R2,609,056/year)
Annual Cost Range: R928,648 difference between highest and lowest
10-Year Impact: R9,286,476 total savings potential

🔧 Individual Pump Overview

Detailed cards view with performance metrics and direct actions for each pump option

BEST MATCH

SCP 150/580HA-132/4

87.2
Overall Score
Efficiency 77.9%
Power 132.2 kW
Head 115.2 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 2

6/8 DME

84.3
Overall Score
Efficiency 80.0%
Power 119.1 kW
Head 106.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 3

6/8 DMP

84.3
Overall Score
Efficiency 80.0%
Power 119.1 kW
Head 106.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 4

6/8 EME

74.5
Overall Score
Efficiency 79.2%
Power 141.7 kW
Head 125.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 5

PJ 200 AS

74.2
Overall Score
Efficiency 64.0%
Power 148.9 kW
Head 106.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 6

VBK 35-22.5 3 STAGE

72.2
Overall Score
Efficiency 66.2%
Power 144.0 kW
Head 106.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 7

PL 200 AN

68.8
Overall Score
Efficiency 78.7%
Power 134.3 kW
Head 118.2 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 8

100-250 2F 2P

68.0
Overall Score
Efficiency 78.0%
Power 122.2 kW
Head 106.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 9

150-125-315

67.2
Overall Score
Efficiency 74.9%
Power 156.6 kW
Head 131.2 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
RANK 10

VBK 35-22 3 Stage

66.7
Overall Score
Efficiency 59.0%
Power 161.5 kW
Head 106.6 m
Impeller mm
Manufacturer APE Pumps
description Full Report
picture_as_pdfDownload Comparison Report arrow_backNew Selection